How To Choose A Butt Plug: Finding The Perfect Fit For You
A few of us have reviewed excellent butt plugs like Nu Sensuelle, Fun Factory’s Boosty, and LELO’s Hugo. But what about those who feel overwhelmed by the sheer size and power of these toys? Maybe you’re unsure where to begin. Do you need help figuring out how to choose a butt plug that suits your comfort level and experience?
Finding the right butt plug can feel intimidating, especially if you’re new to anal play. With so many options, shapes, and materials available, it’s easy to get lost in the choices. But selecting the perfect one doesn’t have to be complicated. By understanding your body, preferences, and comfort level, you can make an informed decision that enhances pleasure without discomfort.
Starting small and prioritizing comfort is key. A beginner-friendly plug should have a tapered tip for easy insertion, a flared base for safety, and a material that suits your needs. If you’re exploring for the first time or looking for something new, the right choice makes all the difference in your experience. Let’s break it down and make finding your ideal butt plug simple and stress-free.
Important Things to Know Before You Start
Every butt plug, no matter the size, follows a similar design. A tapered tip allows for smooth insertion, a narrow neck helps the body grip comfortably, and a flared base prevents unwanted accidents. These features ensure both safety and ease of use, making them essential in any well-designed plug.
For those interested in prostate stimulation, the design changes slightly. A prostate-friendly plug includes a curve that targets the prostate gland, also called the P-spot. This shape enhances pleasure by applying pressure to the right area during wear or movement. Choosing a plug with the right curve can maximize sensation and create a more intense experience.
When browsing options, focus on these four key features: a tapered tip, a secure neck, a flared base, and, if needed, a prostate-friendly curve. Understanding these basics makes it easier to learn how to choose a butt plug that fits your needs. Picking a well-designed plug creates a more comfortable, safe, and pleasurable experience from the very beginning.
A Beginner’s Guide to Anal Play: Products, Tips, and Essential Rules
This guide will introduce you to quality butt plug manufacturers you may not know much about. Exploring new brands can help you find the best fit for your comfort and pleasure.
Starting anal play can feel intimidating, but it doesn’t have to be. A tight-arse guide makes the process simple, helping you ease into it with confidence. Small adjustments can make all the difference, and a few key tips will ensure a smoother, more enjoyable experience.
There’s no single right or wrong way to enjoy sex, but anal play requires extra care. Following essential guidelines ensures that pleasure comes without discomfort. Understanding lubrication, relaxation, and proper preparation can prevent unnecessary pain and make the experience more satisfying.
If you’re learning how to choose a butt plug, knowing these basics sets you up for success. The right approach transforms hesitation into confidence, making the journey into anal play exciting rather than overwhelming. Keep an open mind, take your time, and enjoy the process safely.
How To Choose a Butt Plug: What material is best?
Picking the right material plays a huge role in comfort, safety, and overall experience. If you’re new to anal play, silicone and jelly butt plugs are excellent choices. Both materials are lightweight, soft, and flexible, making them ideal for beginners who need something gentle. A softer texture allows for easier insertion and a more forgiving feel, reducing the chances of discomfort.
For those who want a slightly firmer option, the BASIX Rubber Works Beginner’s Butt Plug by Pipedream is a great choice. It still has some softness but offers enough structure to make insertion easier. A firmer plug helps provide better control, making the experience smoother as you adjust to the sensation.
No matter which material you choose, key safety features remain essential. A flared base prevents accidents, a tapered tip allows for gentle entry, and a slim neck ensures the plug stays comfortably in place. These beginner-friendly plugs keep things simple without extra frills, making them perfect for anyone learning how to choose a butt plug that feels just right.
How Do You Use a Butt Plug?
Before getting started, a high-quality lubricant is essential. A good anal lubricant reduces friction, enhances comfort, and makes the experience far more enjoyable. Pjur’s range of anal relaxant lubricants like Analyse Me and Back Door work well because they are thicker than standard silicone lubes. Their long-lasting formula provides better cushioning, helping you ease into anal play without discomfort.
Generously apply lubricant to both the toy and yourself. With butt plugs, patience is key. There’s no need to rush. Insert the plug slowly, allowing your body to adjust. Sitting still for a few minutes after insertion can help you get used to the sensation before experimenting with movement. Pay attention to how your body responds and let comfort guide you.
The best advice for anyone learning how to choose a butt plug and use it properly is simple. Trust your body. If something feels off, stop and reassess. Never force insertion and don’t push through discomfort. Relax, breathe, and take your time exploring. The more comfortable and patient you are, the better the experience will be.
How Do You Choose Your Next Butt Plug?
Once you’ve decided that anal play is enjoyable, you may want to explore larger sizes. Stepping up gradually allows your body to adjust comfortably, preventing discomfort while enhancing pleasure. This is where sets like A-Zone Max Passion Silicone Ring Plugs become useful. With three different sizes, this set helps you transition smoothly from beginner to intermediate levels without feeling overwhelmed.
Each plug in the set varies in width and length, providing a steady progression. They are soft yet firm, designed with maximum comfort in mind. Made from 100% silicone, these plugs also feature a convenient ring at the base for easy removal. The combination of flexibility and support makes them an excellent choice for those looking to expand their experience.
Now that you feel completely comfortable, you might consider exploring different materials. Glass and surgical steel butt plugs offer a unique sensation and a luxurious aesthetic. These materials are smooth, body-safe, and weightier, providing a different kind of stimulation. Many also come in beautifully designed shapes and colors, making them as visually appealing as they are pleasurable. Learning how to choose a butt plug that suits your evolving preferences ensures continued enjoyment and comfort.
Main Things to Consider with a Butt Plug
Start small. Your excitement might draw you to those jeweled beauties or extra-large toys, but your body will thank you for easing in. Choosing a manageable size ensures a comfortable and pleasurable experience rather than discomfort or regret. Rushing into something too big can lead to pain, strain, or even injury.
Material matters just as much as size. Softer options like TPR jelly or silicone provide a gentler experience, making them ideal for beginners. These materials are flexible, lightweight, and easier to maneuver. Silicone, in particular, is body-safe, non-porous, and easy to clean, making it one of the best choices for long-term use.
Lubrication is non-negotiable. Unlike the vagina, the anus does not self-lubricate, so using a high-quality lubricant is essential. A thick, long-lasting lube prevents friction and discomfort, making insertion and wear more enjoyable. This step is crucial for both beginners and experienced users alike.
Only move up in size when you feel completely comfortable. Forcing yourself to advance too quickly can ruin the experience and cause unnecessary discomfort. Learning how to choose a butt plug that fits your body’s current comfort level ensures that each step of the journey remains pleasurable and safe.
Final Safety Tip
Before using any anal toy, always check for imperfections. This is especially important with glass and steel plugs. Run your fingers along the surface to feel for ridges, seams, or uneven textures. Even the slightest flaw can cause irritation or, in severe cases, lasting damage to one of the body’s most sensitive areas. Taking five seconds to inspect a new toy can save you from discomfort or injury.
Quality control varies between manufacturers, so never assume a toy is flawless straight from the box. If you notice rough edges or an uneven finish, avoid using it. High-quality glass and surgical steel should have a completely smooth, polished surface to ensure safe and comfortable play.
Now that you understand the basics, you’re ready to explore new sensations with confidence. Choosing the right size, material, and lubricant makes a world of difference. Learning how to choose a butt plug that suits your needs ensures that your journey into self-exploration remains safe, pleasurable, and stress-free. Take your time, listen to your body, and most importantly, enjoy the experience.
My Time To Choose A Butt Plug – My First Time
My boyfriend has always been the adventurous type when it comes to intimacy. He loves trying new things, pushing boundaries, and keeping things exciting. So when he casually brought up the idea of trying something different, I wasn’t sure what to expect. The last time we had a “new experience” together, I ended up covered in sundae toppings. Safe to say, I’ve learned to be a little cautious.
This time, he asked if I would ever consider anal play. My immediate reaction was hesitation. I had always been taught that it was off-limits, a no-go zone. But I couldn’t ignore the fact that some of my closest friends had raved about how amazing it could be. They swore that the orgasms were stronger, longer-lasting, and unlike anything else. The curiosity started creeping in.
Sensing my uncertainty, he reassured me that I didn’t have to dive in headfirst. Instead, he suggested that I ease into it by starting with a beginner-friendly butt plug. He explained that using one would help me get comfortable with the sensation, making the idea of full anal sex less intimidating. I had never given it serious thought before, but the way he framed it made sense. Maybe this wasn’t such a crazy idea after all. Maybe it was time to learn how to choose a butt plug and see where this new experience could take us.
I Did my Research on Butt Plugs!!
Once I decided to give anal play a try, I dove headfirst into research. I wanted to know everything. Things like what type of butt plugs were best for beginners, how to prepare, and what to expect. The more I read, the more overwhelmed I became. Some of the information made it sound easy, but other parts had me genuinely nervous. Was this really something I could handle?
Rather than let my imagination run wild, I decided to visit my local adult toy store and ask questions. The salesperson was incredibly helpful, answering everything with patience and detail. They reassured me that my concerns were completely normal, especially for a first-timer. Having someone knowledgeable explain things in person made me feel much more confident.
Then came the real moment of truth. I followed the salesperson into a back room filled with more adult toys than I had ever seen in my life. It was like stepping into a warehouse of dildos, vibrators, and pleasure products I didn’t even know existed. When we reached the butt plug section, I was immediately struck by the size differences. Some were tiny and non-threatening, while others looked like they belonged in a completely different category of human experience. This was the moment I realized I needed to be smart about how to choose a butt plug that wouldn’t scare me off before I even got started.
Exploring the World of Butt Plugs – Choose A Butt Plug
As I stood in front of the display, I couldn’t believe the variety of sizes. Some were barely an inch around, small and unintimidating. Then there were the monsters, massive plugs over five inches in girth that looked downright impossible. I knew right away that starting small was the only logical choice.
There were beginner-friendly kits that included a butt plug, a numbing agent, and a bottle of lubricant. Others came individually packaged, giving you the freedom to mix and match. Then there were the truly wild options, plugs with animal tails, ones covered in spikes, vibrating plugs, and even glass ones that looked more like art pieces than sex toys. The sheer variety was overwhelming but also fascinating.
After taking my time, I finally made my decision. I picked out a small, jelly-style butt plug that seemed perfect for a beginner. It was soft, flexible, and a reassuring shade of blue. At just under two inches around, it felt like a safe starting point. To make sure I was fully prepared, I also grabbed a bottle of water-based lubricant and a numbing lube called AnalEase. This was really happening. I was about to learn firsthand how to choose a butt plug that worked for me.
Facing My First-Time Fears
I won’t lie, I was ridiculously nervous. The idea of putting something in that area felt intimidating, not just because it was new, but because of all the horror stories I had read. Hygiene concerns, awkward mishaps, and the dreaded “what if something goes wrong” thoughts kept running through my mind.
Every website I researched recommended the same preparation routine. Use the bathroom first, take a shower, and make sure you feel as clean and comfortable as possible. I wasn’t about to skip any steps, so I followed the advice to the letter. By the time I finished, I felt fresh, confident, and as ready as I could be.
My boyfriend, ever the supportive partner, could tell I was overthinking everything. He reassured me, kept things lighthearted, and made sure I stayed relaxed. Knowing he wasn’t in any rush helped a lot. His patience made me feel safe, and that was exactly what I needed. I was still nervous, but at least now, I wasn’t letting fear take over. I reminded myself that this was supposed to be fun. Learning how to choose a butt plug had been a journey in itself, but now it was finally time to try it.
Taking the First Step – Choose A Butt Plug
The first thing I had to do was apply the AnalEase. This lubricant numbs the area slightly, making anal play more comfortable without completely dulling sensation. The application process felt a little awkward since I had to use my finger to insert it. At first, I wasn’t sure how I felt about the slight numbing effect, but after a minute or two, I realized it was just enough to ease my nerves without making me feel disconnected.
When my boyfriend’s fingers slid inside, it felt strange at first. Not painful, just different. My body tensed, but he was patient, moving slowly and giving me time to adjust. After a few minutes, I felt myself relaxing, letting go of the initial discomfort, and focusing on the sensations. Once he could tell I was ready, he pulled back and reached for the butt plug.
He coated the toy in a generous amount of water-based lubricant, adding a little extra to me for good measure. Then I felt him press the plug against my entrance. There was a deep pressure that took me by surprise, but he moved slowly, letting me breathe and adjust. Each second that passed made it easier, and before I knew it, the plug was fully inserted. I stayed still for a moment, allowing my body to get used to the new sensation. This was it. I had officially taken the plunge, and learning how to choose a butt plug had led me to this surprisingly exciting moment.
A Whole New Level of Pleasure
As time passed, my body fully adjusted to the butt plug, and that’s when things started to feel incredible. Every small movement sent waves of sensation through me. Whether it was during foreplay or intercourse, the gentle pressure against my most sensitive nerves heightened everything. Even the slightest bump against the plug sent a spark through my entire body.
It felt like my pleasure had been amplified in ways I never expected. Every touch, every thrust, every shift in position created an intensity I had never experienced before. It was as if my whole body had been set on fire, but in the best possible way. The orgasms were deeper, stronger, and far more overwhelming than I had imagined they could be.
When we finally came down from that mind-blowing high, I was relieved to find that removal was just as easy as insertion. A deep breath, a little patience, and the plug slid out smoothly without any discomfort. Learning how to choose a butt plug had led me to a whole new world of pleasure, and in that moment, I knew this wouldn’t be the last time I explored it.
The Unexpected Aftereffects – Choose A Butt Plug
As soon as the butt plug was removed, I felt incredibly sensitive. The empty sensation was almost as intense as when it was inside me. My body had gotten used to the pressure, and without it, everything felt hyper-aware. It wasn’t painful, just different.
However, after a few minutes, I noticed a lingering soreness. The pressure of having something inside me for an extended period had left its mark. This was one thing that none of the guides or research had fully prepared me for. Everything I read had focused on insertion, pleasure, and removal, but barely anything mentioned the aftereffects.
It made complete sense. My body had experienced something entirely new, and naturally, there would be some soreness afterward. For a first-time experience, it was completely normal. It wasn’t unbearable, just a dull ache reminding me of what had just happened. I realized that learning how to choose a butt plug was only part of the journey. Understanding how my body reacted to it was just as important, and now I knew exactly what to expect for next time.
Cleaning Your Butt Plug the Right Way
Once the fun is over, proper cleaning is essential. Skipping this step or doing it carelessly can lead to infections or bacteria buildup. No matter how tired or satisfied you feel, taking a few extra minutes to clean your toy thoroughly is a must.
The best method is using warm water and a specialized toy cleaner. These cleaners are designed to disinfect without damaging the material. If you don’t have a toy cleaner, a mild, unscented soap works as a backup. Harsh soaps or alcohol-based products can break down the material, especially with jelly or silicone plugs, making them unsafe for future use.
After washing, let the plug air dry. Towels can leave behind lint or fuzz, which can transfer to your body the next time you use it. Once dry, store it in a clean, dust-free container. I personally use a small plastic case to keep mine safe and hygienic. Proper storage keeps your toy in good condition and ensures that when you’re ready to use it again, it’s completely clean and ready to go. Learning how to choose a butt plug is important, but knowing how to care for it properly is just as essential.
My Butt Plug is Now a Favorite – Choose A Butt Plug
After that first experience, my butt plug quickly became one of my favorite toys. What started as curiosity had turned into something my boyfriend and I genuinely enjoyed together. When we have enough time to fully relax and take things slow, it makes our intimate moments even more intense.
Over time, I started experimenting with larger sizes. At first, I wasn’t sure if I would ever want to go beyond that small, beginner-friendly plug. But as I became more comfortable, I found myself wanting to take the next step. Now, I have moved up in size and I plan to continue exploring at my own pace.
Using a butt plug is a unique experience, one that I never imagined I would love this much. If there is one thing I have learned, it is that being open to new sensations can lead to mind-blowing discoveries. Learning how to choose a butt plug was only the beginning. I truly believe everyone should try it at least once because you never know what you might end up loving.
Enter Andrew Pullen’s BDSM world of Fet Lifestyle, BDSM, and expert Shibari insights. Explore his descriptive and educational articles at Adultsmart.
Leave a Reply